Update Magazine II/2020 DOWNLOAD THE COMPLETE MAGAZINE
	GO TO E-PAPER

1 

Introduction

The opening of the China A-share market to foreign investors and the subsequent growing inclusion of a much larger number of Chinese companies in widely used equity indices is poised to be, in our view, one of the most transformative events in the financial markets over the next decade. The implications for investors are numerous, complex and, above all, inevitable, making the maintenance of the status quo, in our view, an unviable solution. 

Investors considering an investment in the domestic China A-share market are now able to tap into the full China equity pool, with a significantly larger market capitalisation than Europe, for example. The A-share market alone encompasses more than 3,700 listed companies worth nearly $8.8 trillion across the entire market-capitalisation spectrum (see Chart A/). That’s comparable to the $9.3 trillion market capitalisation of equities in the euro area.³

In this paper, we argue that an allocation to China A-shares presents a unique opportunity for investors to optimise their global equity portfolios.

Our analysis shows that the Chinese domestic market exhibits low correlation with other widely held asset classes (such as Hong Kong-listed H-shares as well as US and European equities), a trait that stems from the fact that; a) the Chinese domestic market is influenced by unique economic, political and monetary policy considerations, and; b) it has very different market participants than elsewhere. In addition, because these companies generate the vast majority of their revenues domestically, the effects of ongoing trade tensions with the US are less pronounced than may be commonly assumed.

Also, we explain why we believe that – given China’s long- term economic growth prospects as well as the stillabundant inefficiencies seen in the country’s domestic equity market – an investment in China A-shares exhibits superior alpha-generating potential. 

Lastly, we present our views on the future evolution of the market – as well as its growing representation in equity benchmarks – and weave our thoughts on how investors should consider tapping this market, as well as what potential impact an allocation to China A-shares may have on existing portfolios.

All in all, we see this as an evolving story, for both the China A-share market itself – which, we expect, should continue to grow and modernise – and Western investors – who, we believe, should take a progressive approach to allocating to this momentous asset class.

A/    CHINA A-SHARES GIVE FOREIGN INVESTORS BROAD ACCESS TO A SIGNIFICANT OPPORTUNITY

As of January 31, 2020
Only the market cap of the listed share class is included. Offshore China stocks are defined based on companies with ultimate parent domiciled in China. Suspended stocks are excluded.
Source: Nasdaq, Shanghai Stock Exchange, Shenzhen Stock Exchange, Bloomberg, Allianz Global Investors

2 

A long path to access, but a potentially rewarding one nonetheless

Before 2003, foreign investors could only trade some Chinese firms listed on the Hong Kong Stock Exchange (H-shares), which is dominated by state-owned enterprises, such as banks and energy firms, or American Depositary Receipts (ADRs) traded in the United States. Together, H-shares and ADRs are known as “offshore China.”

Access improved in 2003, with the launch of the Qualified Foreign Institutional Investor (QFII) program, which offered foreign investors access via quotas to China A-shares – listed in the Shenzhen and Shanghai bourses (known as “onshore China”) and traded in renminbi. The RMB Qualified Foreign Institutional Investor (RQFII) Scheme, launched in late 2011, further expanded access by allowing Chinese financial firms to establish renminbi-denominated funds in Hong Kong for investment in the mainland.

Subsequently, the launches of the Shanghai-Hong Kong Stock Connect Program in 2014 and the Shenzhen Connect Program in 2016 gave foreigners access to Shanghai- and Shenzhen-listed stocks, without quotas or the need for a licence. Importantly, these Stock Connect programs also significantly lowered the costs of accessing the Chinese onshore market. Finally, on June 1, 2018, MSCI added China A-shares into its emerging market indices for the first time.

Although it was a long road until foreign investors gained access to China’s domestic stock market, we believe that investors will come to realise that it might have been worth the wait given the size and scope of the opportunity.

Now the second-largest economy globally, China is forecast to overtake the United States as the world’s largest economy by 2030. That growing economic importance will increasingly be reflected in global equity indices and in portfolios. Further, adding China A-shares to portfolios adds meaningful diversification, as evidenced by China A-shares’ low historic correlation with major equity markets globally. Two main reasons are behind this low correlation (see Chart B/).

First, the Chinese domestic equity market is, by many measures, still in its infancy. Trading is still dominated by retail investors (more on that later) and the regulatory environment – albeit evolving quickly – remains volatile and susceptible to the vicissitudes and trends of the Chinese domestic political environment.

Second, the companies trading in this market sell primarily to local consumers. In fact, China A-shares companies yield 90% of their revenue domestically, in many cases leaving them well placed to avoid significant negative impacts associated with ongoing trade tensions with the US. This local revenue base makes them less sensitive to global macro-economic trends, and more sensitive to the directions set by both the Chinese government and the People’s Bank of China, the country’s central bank. Traditionally, Chinese fiscal and monetary policies have “marched to their own beat,” and have not been highly correlated to the policies adopted by the US and other Western monetary authorities.

B/    BECAUSE OF DOMESTIC REVENUES AND DISTINCT ECONOMIC AND MONETARY POLICY, CHINA A-SHARES HAVE A LOW CORRELATION WITH MAJOR EQUITY MARKETS

As of January 31, 2020
Correlation data is calculated based on historical return of respective MSCI indices for the past 10 years, using weekly USD return.
Source: Bloomberg, Allianz Global Investors

3 

China A-shares and the promise of the “new economy”

In addition to the low-correlation factor, the China A-share market provides an entry door for investors to more deeply benefit from China’s ongoing shift from an export-driven economy into the so-called “new economy,” characterised by an increased role for domestic consumption and higher-value-added sectors, such as tourism, entertainment, healthcare equipment, industrial automation, new energy vehicles, biotech, software and new materials.

As shown in Chart C/ , investing in China A-shares gives investors greater access to the small- and mid-cap companies set to be the future drivers for China’s economic growth – technology, innovation and the rapidly expanding Chinese middle class. In fact, more than half of China’s economic output comes from the services sector, and the country is a major investor in, and adopter of, digital technologies. So, China Ashares – especially when accessed through non-passive instruments – better reflect the promise of the country’s digital future than emerging-market benchmarks such as the MSCI Emerging Markets Index, which is highly biased towards Chinese mega-and large-cap stocks.

C/    CHINA A-SHARES BETTER REFLECT FASTER-GROWING SECTORS OF THE “NEW ECONOMY”

CHINA ALL SHARES INDEX, INDEX BREAKDOWN BY LISTING LOCATION

As of January 31, 2020
Data analysis based on the MSCI All China Index (broken down by sector and stock exchange).
Source: Bloomberg, Allianz Global Investors

4 

Buying the MSCI EM Index alone is not the ideal way to boost China exposure

Today, most investors benchmark their exposure to China to international equity (i.e. MSCI ACWI ex-US) and/or global emerging market (i.e. MCSI EM) indices. But simply increasing allocations to those indices may not be an ideal way to broaden China exposure. 

Here’s why: although China A-shares are now included in MSCI indices, their weighting within the MSCI EM Index and MSCI ACWI Index are, as of this writing, just 4.1% and 0.5%, respectively. To put that into context, the market cap of China A-shares as a percentage of global equities was 9% (at the end of 2019) and the overall Chinese economy accounted for 15.8% of global economic output in 2018.⁵ As the numbers show, China A-shares are considerably under-represented in one of the benchmarks most widely used by investors.

The current Chinese exposure within the MSCI EM Index is weighted heavily toward low-growth companies, and concentrated in a few mega-cap technology firms, such as Alibaba and Tencent.⁶ This extra “mega/large-cap bias” creates further imbalances for investors seeking to establish an exposure to Chinese equities that is concomitant to the current growth opportunity for that market.

In this context, we argue that a direct allocation to China A-shares – especially when done through non-passive instruments – can provide investors with a more well-adjusted exposure to the Chinese market. For example, investing in A-shares gives investors greater access to a plethora of opportunities among small- and mid-cap companies. As illustrated in Chart D/, 38.1% of the MSCI China A-Shares Onshore Index is represented by small- and mid-cap companies with a market cap below $10 billion, compared to 14.2% in offshore China.

Further, while it’s certainly a positive step that MSCI has begun adding China A-shares to its key MSCI EM Index, representation will likely remain very small and, in our view, artificially depressed. From this perspective, we don’t believe that investors who decide to define their China A-share exposure by simply “buying the MSCI EM Index” will be properly positioned to seize this opportunity in the next few years.

D/    CHINA A-SHARES COMPLEMENT CHINA STOCKS IN THE MSCI EM INDEX AND OFFER A PLETHORA OF OPPORTUNITIES AMONG MID- AND SMALL-CAP COMPANIES

As of January 31, 2020
Source: Bloomberg, Allianz Global Investors

That said, we do expect that the A-share weightings of the MSCI EM Index will increase significantly over time to reflect the size of China A-share markets, altering the composition of future EM benchmarks. Chart E/ extrapolates what China weights would look like in the MSCI EM index if those weights were calculated by; a) the current selected number of China A-shares included in the index, and; b) by all shares currently trading in the China A-shares market.

As Chart E/ shows, China would account for 43% of the index in the first scenario, and 50% of the index in the second one. Although we don’t expect those levels of exposure will be reached any time in the foreseeable future, the analysis does reiterate an important issue: investors seeking to be “ahead of the curve” to fully capture the current opportunity in the Chinese equity market are unlikely to achieve that goal by simply sticking to current benchmark weights.

E/    CHINA A-SHARES ARE SUBSTANTIALLY UNDER-REPRESENTED IN THE MSCI EMERGING MARKET INDEX

As of February, 2020
Middle chart is based on MSCI’s proposal in November 2019 to include 472 large- and mid-cap China A-shares stocks into the MSCI Emerging Market index. Right chart is based on the assumption that all China stocks are available to be included in the MSCI Emerging Market index. We use a 85% discount factor, which should approximately represent the large- and mid-cap universe within China A-shares.
Source: MSCI, Bank of America Merrill Lynch, Allianz Global Investors

5 

Understanding China A-share risks and how to mitigate them

While the China A-share market represents a significant opportunity, it carries risks. We expect that the increased access to China A-shares and the rising importance of the country’s economy will attract greater participation from investors. Nevertheless, the market for now remains dominated by retail investors. Indeed, domestic retail investors, primarily focused on chasing short-term trading profits, account for more than 80% of daily turnover. Also, local Chinese equity analysts tend to be less experienced than is the case in developed markets, leading to a greater frequency of earnings surprises than in more mature markets.

As shown in Chart F/ all this contributes to higher volatility – something underlined in June 2018, when onshore China suffered declines of nearly 11%. There is also higher sector rotation for China A-shares compared to developed-market indices, and a high dispersion of returns. Exacerbating risks, while the regulatory environment is evolving at a fast pace, it remains fairly unpredictable.

F/    CHINA A-SHARE STOCK SUSPENSIONS HAVE DECLINED

% of China A-share stocks suspended

As of February 20, 2020
Source: Goldman Sachs, Allianz Global Investors

6 

Deploying China A-shares in an institutional portfolio

In light of the current opportunity and the early stage of development of the China A-shares market, investors should, in our view, take an incremental approach to deploying this new asset class in their portfolios.

We consider the case for investing in onshore China today as similar to investing in emerging markets a quarter of a century ago: back then, many investors viewed deploying capital to developing economies (and immature capital markets) as risky. Today, however, an emerging-market allocation is a typical part of any serious investor’s strategic asset allocation. We forecast that allocations to onshore China will follow a similar trajectory.

As mentioned previously, it is our view that the importance of China – and China A-shares in particular – is underrepresented in the benchmark index typically used for emerging-market allocations, falling far short of both the importance of China’s economy and its equity market. Consequently, we believe that adding a more significant allocation to China A-shares as part of a portfolio’s current emerging-market allocation makes sense for both risk-return reasons and for portfolio optimisation, especially given the asset class’s low correlation to other global equities.

The question then becomes, how heavily should an emerging-market allocation tilt toward onshore China? While the precise answer varies among investors, data suggest that the sweet spot may be between a 10% to 30% direct allocation to China A-shares, with the money to fund that allocation coming from investors’ existing emerging-market portfolios.

Using the MSCI EM index as our proxy for a “core” emerging-market portfolio, we compiled historical data from the past 15 years (see Chart G/ and H/) to observe what the impact of adding the MSCI China A-Shares Onshore Index to an MSCI EM index allocation would be on annualised returns and on risk.

G/    ADDING CHINA A-SHARES TO MSCI EM ALLOCATIONS CAN ENHANCE THE RISK/RETURN PROFILE OF AN EMERGING-MARKET ALLOCATION

Chart shows analysis of returns for the MSCI Emerging Market index (used as proxy for global emerging markets) and MSCI China A Onshore index (used as proxy for the China A-share market) indices from January 31, 2005 to January 31, 2020. Percentages shown on the chart represent portion of portfolio allocated to China A-shares.
Source: Allianz Global Investors

As a result, we believe that the time is right for investors to consider increasing allocations to onshore China, as they did with emerging-market allocations a generation ago.

Our analysis reveals that shifting 10% of one’s global emerging-market allocation to China A-shares would improve the overall portfolio return from an annualised 7.5% to 8.3%. And, mainly due to the asset class’s low correlation characteristics, the portfolio’s Sharpe ratio would see a significant enhancement from 0.29 to 0.34.

A bolder shift of 30% of ones allocation to China A-shares would compound the enhancements further, with the annualised return of the overall portfolio rising to 9.7%, and the Sharpe ratio jumping to 0.4. Our 15-year historical risk/ return analysis suggests that a portfolio’s Sharpe ratio would be maximised with an allocation of 50%. While any such historical analysis is very dependent on its start and end points, these results suggest that a meaningful allocation to China A-shares would be beneficial from a portfolio construction perspective.

The historical analysis highlights many of the benefits that investors can reap from allocating to the Chinese onshore equity markets and, we believe, can be used as a starting point when considering exposure to the asset class. Further, we recognise that historical analyses are very start- and end-point sensitive. Those caveats notwithstanding, history and experience have shown us that the Chinese domestic equity market is clearly on an evolutionary path, especially in terms of its outlook for broader investor participation and potential lower volatility.

With that in mind, we firmly believe that it behoves investors to consider an increased allocation to China equity through exposure to the country’s domestic market. But – due to the evidence presented in this paper – investors should deploy capital in a steady yet evolutionary fashion, to benefit from a “first-mover” advantage without overly taxing their risk budgets.⁸

H/    OVERWEIGHTING EMERGING MARKET ALLOCATIONS TO CHINA A-SHARES MAY INCREASE THE RISK-ADJUSTED RETURNS OF PORTFOLIOS

Allocation from global emerging markets to China A-shares

Table shows analysis of returns for the MSCI Emerging Market index (used as proxy for global emerging markets) and MSCI China A Onshore index (used as proxy for the China A-share market) indices from January 31, 2005 to January 31, 2020. Percentages shown in the table represent portion of portfolio allocated to China A-shares. Past performance is not indicative of future results.
Source: Allianz Global Investors

Investing involves risk. The value of an investment and the income from it may fall as well as rise and investors might not get back the full amount invested. The views and opinions expressed herein, which are subject to change without notice, are those of the issuer companies at the time of publication. The data used is derived from various sources, and assumed to be correct and reliable at the time of publication. The conditions of any underlying offer or contract that may have been, or will be, made or concluded, shall prevail. The duplication, publication, or transmission of the contents, irrespective of the form, is not permitted; except for the case of explicit permission by Allianz Global Investors GmbH.

The volatility of fund unit prices may be increased or even strongly increased. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future results. If the currency in which the past performance is displayed differs from the currency of the country in which the investor resides, then the investor should be aware that due to the exchange rate fluctuations the performance shown may be higher or lower if converted into the investor’s local currency. The statements contained herein may include statements of future expectations and other forward-looking statements that are based on management's current views and assumptions and involve known and unknown risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results, performance or events to differ materially from those expressed or implied in such statements. We assume no obligation to update any forward-looking statement.

This is for information only and not to be construed as a solicitation or an invitation to make an offer, to conclude a contract, or to buy or sell any securities. The products or securities described herein may not be available for sale in all jurisdictions or to certain categories of investors. This is for distribution only as permitted by applicable law and in particular not available to residents and/or nationals of the USA. The investment opportunities described herein do not take into account the specific investment objectives, financial situation, knowledge, experience or particular needs of any particular person and are not guaranteed. The views and opinions expressed herein, which are subject to change without notice, are those of the issuer and/or its affiliated companies at the time of publication. The data used is derived from various sources, and assumed to be correct and reliable, but it has not been independently verified; its accuracy or completeness is not guaranteed and no liability is assumed for any direct or consequential losses arising from its use, unless caused by gross negligence or willful misconduct. The conditions of any underlying offer or contract that may have been, or will be, made or concluded, shall prevail.

Contact the issuer electronically or via mail at the address indicated below for a free copy of the sales prospectus, the incorporation documents, the latest annual and semi-annual financial reports and the key investor information document in English. Please read these documents – which are solely binding – carefully before investing.

For investors in Europe (excluding Switzerland): This is a marketing communication issued by Allianz Global Investors GmbH, www.allianzgi.com, an investment company with limited liability, incorporated in Germany, with its registered office at Bockenheimer Landstrasse 42–44, 60323 Frankfurt/M, registered with the local court Frankfurt/M under HRB 9340, authorised by Bundesanstalt für Finanzdienstleistungsaufsicht (www.bafin.de). Allianz Global Investors GmbH has established branches in the United Kingdom, France, Italy, Spain, Luxembourg and the Netherlands. Contact details and information on the local regulation are available here (www.allianzgi.com/Info).

For investors in Switzerland: This is a marketing communication issued by Allianz Global Investors (Schweiz) AG, a 100% subsidiary of Allianz Global Investors GmbH, licensed by FINMA (www.finma.ch) for distribution and by OAKBV (Oberaufsichtskommission berufliche Vorsorge) for asset management related to occupational pensions.. Details about the extent of the local regulation are available from us on request.

This report does not satisfy all legal requirements on the guarantee of impartiality in investment recommendations and investment strategy recommendations and is not subject to any trade restrictions prior to the publication of such recommendations. The duplication, publication, or transmission of the contents, irrespective of the form, is not permitted.

AD ID 1234256, 1230301, 1187248, 1121234, 1212179, 1233257, 1227736